Questionnaire: Scholarly Editions

Philipp Steinkrüger, Torsten Schaßan, and the members of the IDE.

Please fill in all the fields in all the tabs before submitting. Form data cannot be saved and forms cannot be edited at a later stage. Resubmission, though, is possible.

Mandatory fields. Furthermore, please make sure that you answer all questions in the questionnaire below.

Important information concerning individual questions is available via the info-symbol. Please read before answering a question.

Resource reviewed Title: Editors: URI: Publication Date: Date of last access:

Reviewer Surname: First Name: Organization: Place: Email:

Reviewer Surname: First Name: Organization: Place: Email:

Add another reviewer

Documentation

Contents

Presentation

Search

Aim

Method

Accessability

Personnel

Submission

Documentation Bibliographic description

cf. Catalogue 1.2

Is it easily possible to describe the project bibliographically along the schema "responsible editors, publishing/hosting institution, year(s) of publishing"?

yesno

Contributors

cf. Catalogue 1.4

Are the contributors (editors, institutions, associates) of the project fully documented?

yesno

Contacts

cf. Catalogue 1.5

Does the project list contact persons?

yesno

Selection of materials Explanation

cf. Catalogue 2.1

Is the selection of materials of the project explicitly documented?

yesno

Reasonability

cf. Catalogue 2.1

Is the selection by and large reasonable?

yesno

Archiving of the data

cf. Catalogue 4.16

Does the documentation include information about the long term sustainability of the basic data (archiving of the data)?

yesno

Aims

cf. Catalogue 3.1

Are the aims and purposes of the project explicitly documented?

yesno

Methods

cf. Catalogue 3.1

Are the methods employed in the project explicitly documented?

yesno

Data Model

cf. Catalogue 3.7

Does the project document which data model (e.g. TEI) has been used and for what reason?

yesno

Help

cf. Catalogue 4.15

Does the project offer help texts concerning the use of the project?

yesno

Citation

cf. Catalogue 4.8

Does the project supply citation guidelines (i.e. how to cite the project or a part of it)?

yesno

Completion

cf. Catalogue 4.16

Does the editon regard itself as a completed project (i.e. not promise further modifications and additions)?

yesno

Institutional Curation

cf. Catalogue 4.13

Does the project provide information about institutional support for the curation and sustainability of the project?

yesno

Contents Previous Edition

cf. Catalogue 2.2

Has the material been previously edited (in print or digitally)?

yesno

Materials Used

cf. Catalogue 2.2

Does the edition make use of these previous editions?

yesnonot applicable

Introduction

cf. Catalogue 4.15

Does the project offer an introduction to the subject-matter (the author(s), the work, its history, the theme, etc.) of the project?

yesno

Bibliography

cf. Catalogue 2.3

Does the project offer a bibliography?

yesno

Commentary

cf. Catalogue 2.3

Does the project offer a scholarly commentary (e.g. notes on unclear passages, interpretation, etc.)?

yesno

Contexts

cf. Catalogue 2.3

Does the project include or link to external resources with contextual material?

yesno

Images

cf. Catalogue 2.3

Does the project offer images of digitised sources?

yesno

Image quality

cf. Catalogue 4.6

Does the project offer images of an acceptable quality?

yesnonot applicable

Transcriptions

cf. Catalogue 2.3

Is the text fully transcribed?

yesno

Text quality

cf. Catalogue 4.6

Does the project offer texts of an acceptable quality (typos, errors, etc.)?

yesno

Indices

cf. Catalogue 4.5

Does the project feature compilations indices, registers or visualisations that offer alternative ways to access the material?

yesno

Documents Types of documents

cf. Catalogue 1.3 and 2.1

Which kinds of documents are at the basis of the project?

Single manuscript Single work Collection of texts Collected works Papers Archival holding Charters Letters Diary other

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Document era

cf. Catalogue 1.3 and 2.1

What era(s) do the documents belong to?

Classics Medieval Early Modern Modern

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries. Subject

cf. Catalogue 1.3

Which perspective(s) do the editors take towards the edited material? How can the edition be classified in general terms?

History Philology / Literary Studies Philosophy / Theology History of Science Musicology Art History other

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Presentation Spin-offs

cf. Catalogue 4.11

Does the project offer any spin-offs?

App Mobile PDF other none

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Browse by

cf. Catalogue 4.3

By which categories does the project offer to browse the contents?

Authors Works Versions Structure Pages Documents Type of material Images Dates Persons Places other

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Search Simple

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the project offer a simple search?

yesno

Advanced

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the project offer an advanced search?

yesno

Wildcards

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the search support the use of wildcards?

yesnonot applicable

Index

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the search offer an index of the searched field?

yesnonot applicable

Suggest functionalities

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the search offer autocompletion or suggest functionalities?

yesnonot applicable

Helptext

cf. Catalogue 4.4

Does the project offer help texts for the search?

yesnonot applicable

Aim Audience

cf. Catalogue 3.3

Who is the intended audience of the project?

Scholars Interested public

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries. Typology

cf. Catalogue 3.3 and 5.1

Which type fits best for the reviewed project?

Facsimile Edition Archive Edition Documentary Edition Diplomatic Edition Genetic Edition Work Critical Edition Text Critical Edition Enriched Edition Database Edition Digital Library Collection of Texts other none

other:

choose 'other' above

Method Critical editing

cf. Catalogue 3.6

In how far is the text critically edited?

Transmission examined Palaeographic annotations Normalization Variants Emendation Commentary notes other none

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Standards

cf. Catalogue 3.7

XML

Is the data encoded in XML?

yesno

Standardized data model

Is the project employing a standardized data model (e.g. TEI)?

yesno

Types of text

cf. Catalogue 3.5.

Which kinds or forms of text are presented?

Facsimiles Diplomatic transcription Edited text Translations Commentaries Semantic data

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

Technical accessability Persistent Identification and Addressing

cf. Catalogue 4.8

Are there persistent identifiers and an addressing system for the edition and/or parts/objects of it and which mechanism is used to that end?

DOI ARK URN PURL.ORG other service Persistent URLs none

other:

choose 'other' above

Interfaces

cf. Catalogue 4.9

Are there technical interfaces like OAI-PMH, REST etc., which allow the reuse of the data of the project in other contexts?

OAI-PMH REST General API other none

Hold the Ctrl/CMD key to select multiple entries.

other:

choose 'other' above

Open Access

Is the edition Open Access?

yesno

Accessability of the basic data

cf. Catalogue 4.12

Is the basic data (e.g. the XML) of the project accessible for each part of the edition (e.g. for a page)?

yesno

Download

cf. Catalogue 4.9

Can the entire raw data of the project be downloaded (as a whole)?

yesno

Reuse

cf. Catalogue 4.9

Can you use the data with other tools useful for this kind of content?

yesno

Rights Declared

cf. Catalogue 4.13

Are the rights to (re)use the content declared?

yesno

License

cf. Catalogue 4.13

Under what license are the contents released?

CC0 CC-BY CC-BY-ND CC-BY-NC CC-BY-SA CC-BY-NC-ND CC-BY-NC-SA PDM other Multiple licences No explicit license / all rights reserved

other:

choose 'other' above

Personnel

Please indicate the involved personnel by name (forename surname) and their respective roles.

Choose 'Contributor' if no other role is applicable.

Add a new entry

Editor Encoder Programmer Advisor Designer Contributor

Editor Encoder Programmer Advisor Designer Contributor

Before submitting, please make sure that you have filled out all the mandatory fields in the "Resource reviewed" and "Reviewer" sections, as well as all the fields in all the tabs. Validation errors will be shown below as long as there are missing fields.

MISSING: Resource, Title

MISSING: Resource, Editors

MISSING: Resource, Publication Date

MISSING: Resource, Date of last access

MISSING: Reviewer, First Name

MISSING: Reviewer, Surname

MISSING: Reviewer, Email

MISSING: Documentation, Bibliographic description

MISSING: Documentation, Contributors

MISSING: Documentation, Contacts

MISSING: Documentation, Explanation

MISSING: Documentation, Reasonability

MISSING: Documentation, Archiving of the data

MISSING: Documentation, Aims

MISSING: Documentation, Methods

MISSING: Documentation, Data Model

MISSING: Documentation, Help

MISSING: Documentation, Citation

MISSING: Documentation, Completion

MISSING: Documentation, Institutional Curation

MISSING: Contents, Previous Edition

MISSING: Contents, Materials Used

MISSING: Contents, Introduction

MISSING: Contents, Bibliography

MISSING: Contents, Commentary

MISSING: Contents, Contexts

MISSING: Contents, Images

MISSING: Contents, Image quality

MISSING: Contents, Transcriptions

MISSING: Contents, Text quality

MISSING: Contents, Indices

MISSING: Contents, Types of documents

MISSING: Contents, Document era

MISSING: Contents, Subject

MISSING: Presentation, Spin-offs

MISSING: Presentation, Browse by

MISSING: Search, Simple

MISSING: Search, Advanced

MISSING: Search, Wildcards

MISSING: Search, Index

MISSING: Search, Suggest functionalities

MISSING: Search, Helptext

MISSING: Aim, Audience

MISSING: Aim, Typology

MISSING: Method, Critical editing

MISSING: Method, XML

MISSING: Method, Standardized data model

MISSING: Method, Types of text

MISSING: Accessability, Persistent Identification and Addressing

MISSING: Accessability, Interfaces

MISSING: Accessability, Open Access

MISSING: Accessability, Accessability of the basic data

MISSING: Accessability, Download

MISSING: Accessability, Reuse

MISSING: Accessability, Rights declared

MISSING: Accessability, License

MISSING: Personnel, Roles

MISSING: Personnel, Names

When you press "Submit", it may take some seconds until the questionnaire has been sent.

submit all

reset all